How do you properly request a court reporter's transcript for an appeal in Texas?
This question has been addressed in 2 Texas court opinions:
Vallecillo v. Gonzalez
COA04 — January 28, 2026
In Vallecillo v. Gonzalez, an appellant seeking to challenge a take-nothing judgment submitted only a partial reporter's record to the appellate court to save on transcript costs. However, the appellant failed to file a contemporaneous 'statement of points or issues' as required by Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 34.6(c). The Fourth Court of Appeals analyzed the case under the common-law presumption that any omitted portions of a record are presumed to support the trial court's judgment. Because the appellant's own case-in-chief was among the missing volumes and he failed to trigger the 'safe harbor' protections of Rule 34.6, the court held it was legally impossible to sustain his sufficiency challenges and affirmed the trial court's ruling.
Litigation Takeaway
“When appealing a case with a partial transcript, you must file a formal 'Statement of Points or Issues'; otherwise, the court will automatically presume that the missing testimony supports the judge's original decision, likely tanking your appeal.”
Bravo v. Bravo
COA02 — February 5, 2026
In Bravo v. Bravo, a Husband challenged a final divorce decree that appointed the Wife as sole managing conservator, denied him all access to his children, and ordered child support. He argued he received only four days' notice of the trial and that the evidence was insufficient to support the findings. The Fort Worth Court of Appeals analyzed the case under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 245 and the Texas Rules of Appellate Procedure. The court held that because the Husband's attorney appeared and announced 'ready' at trial, any objection to the 45-day notice requirement was waived. Furthermore, because the Husband failed to provide a reporter’s record (the transcript of the trial), the court applied an irrebuttable presumption that the evidence presented at trial was sufficient to support the judge's rulings. The appellate court affirmed the trial court's decree in its entirety.
Litigation Takeaway
“Procedural technicalities can win or lose an appeal before it even begins. In Texas family law, if your attorney announces 'ready' for a hearing, you waive any right to complain about lack of notice. Additionally, you cannot win an appeal based on 'lack of evidence' if you fail to provide the appellate court with the transcript of the trial; without that record, the court will automatically assume the trial judge had enough evidence to make their ruling.”